More from The Dotabuff Blog
17 commenti
horatio13

    I wrote a long response but then deleting it after realizing that the existence of neutral camp pull nullified my argument. Now I think that there is no need to "fix" things that work in ways different to the original intention unless it becomes "broken" or deeply contradictory to the lore/physics in such a way that it makes the hero or heroes weird to play (ie tiny toss buyback).

    Metsis

      You really cannot possibly capture all weird interactions from a game as complex as this. There will always be something that is weird and shouldn't be happening the way it is happening. A large portion of these are mostly harmless and it is basically just a "quirk" and does not effect gameplay all that much. But the true scholars of the game can find meaning where there seemingly is none and finds a way to exploit it in some way that makes the other team cry...

      And I believe the top teams have a trick or two again up their sleeves to pull out at TI and it will be glorious again. That IO carry thing was just marvelous... Fountain Hook was quite ingenious too... I cannot wait for what's next. It will most likely be mind blowing again. And then the pubs are going to be stupid as people try to do it in shit tier dota, where I reside.

      Strakog

        The developers of the game decide which things are features and which ones are bugs, that's the long and short of it. Maybe they didn't fix the toss bug before because they deemed that it had negligible impact in the game, and when they saw that it actually changed the course of a (European*) match completely, they reconsidered.

        *The same bug appeared in a SA pro competition but as it was SA, nobody in Valve cared, apparently.

        The_Jiten

          But the sad part is, they fixed Timbersaw + Tiny toss without changing Pudge. If you die while being dragged by hook and BB immediately, you respawn in fountain and then immediately tp to pudge's location... Where is the consistency?

          mllcg

            As long as pros do it, it will be removed

            Entertainment 7wenty

              I saw they also got rid of Timber's chain/buyback with the patch, I'm assuming because of the same reason. But as far as I know you can still to it with Puck and Illusory Orb/buyback as well as Spectre/Haunt to quickly buyback and free tp back into fight. It seem arbitrary to pick and choose what heroes get this ability.

              Fathomorg

                Neutral creeps being pulled is something that can be easily accounted for and mirrored by both sides. Faceless void using Chrono to set up for an Ice Blast is simply an intended combo as two heroes synergize the core mechanics of their kit; fountain hooks used a niche spell of Chen that wasn't necessarily hero-defining. When it comes to unusual interactions, they're acceptable when they meet a set of criteria for being balanced, intended design, and encourage diverse playstyles. There are some heroes that are "dedicated cheese" like huskar and usually brood; but reliable staples imploring cheese strats can be really difficult to read. Heroes are traditionally reworked often because they do too much or too little of their core design to the point that their intended playstyle is no longer viable. I expect sometime in the near future that sniper will be completely reworked as a hero mostly because he hasn't been a viable core in well over a year and there are still people even playing him support with aghs. I think it's likely that headshot and take aim get combined into a new ability, concussive grenade becomes a basic ability with more range, and he gets a shard upgrade that improves his core potential.

                Questo commento è stato modificato
                hell

                  It's a dick move,like they just showing look, game exists only for the pros, don't matter if you playing pubs and getting stomped by all those bugs, the moment a pro player is affected by it, we will fix it, kinda shows how low they value individual not a pro player

                  Dreadnought325

                    These bug fixes dont really affect pubs, so they didnt change it. It is now harder to abuse a certain mechanic, fun days are over.

                    Chawrizaurd

                      Well, I am ancient scrub, but I think bugs unfairly reward/punish, disproportional to the amount of skill and resource spent. Meaning it either reward too much without the appropriate amount of resource/skill being spent or punish too hard with the lack thereof.

                      For the SS chrono ice blast, that is 3 ults being used at the same time, so the reward for pulling it off should be huge, and the other team should be punish if they group up like idiots.

                      For fountain hook, while the amount of skills required is high, and the drawbacks of failure is huge (4v5 a fight), the reward of instantly removing 1 hero from the game even with aegis seems broken.

                      Tiny's toss buyback interaction to me falls into bugs: when you die and want to return to the fight again, speed is important. There should be a positive reinforcement cycle: you return as fast as possible to reposition yourself into a fight, rewarding reflexes and decision making with team fight advantage. However, the toss instead punishes you for having high reflexes, causing you to respawn in a terrible position, creating a negative reinforcement cycle: you are punished for being too good.

                      Joseppi128

                        @Entertainment 7wenty, I see what you're saying, but consider player agency as the key factor, not arbitrariness. In order to execute the bb trick for Puck and Spec, the player has to cast a specific spell after buying back. The Tiny and Timber interactions attached a drastic side-effect to the buyback button that couldn't be changed by the affected player.

                        Questo commento è stato modificato
                        Megu is my waifu!!

                          weaver death buyback and timelapse still there

                          FLOCCOUSTIC

                            Any hero just respawn if get glimpse still back to where they died last

                            Nemesis 041

                              The Tiny, Timbersaw, and by extension, Pudge interactions feel like bug fixes because not only could they be abused, but they could be MISused. Buying back and returning to combat with things like Waver's Time Lapse, Spectre's Haunt, Puck's Illusory Orb, and things like that are choices that can be made by the player of those heroes, but if you were to do so whilst being tossed by Tiny, timber chaining somewhere by Timbersaw, or being hooked by Pudge, there are an equal amount of times that would be an accident than it would be intentional. Additionally, enemies could also fall victim to Pudge's and Tiny's interactions, with further supports my thinking.

                              Dee Doga

                                Вивер по прежнему может байбекнуться и вернуться на ульте в файт, почему не убрали чем этот баг хуже тоса?

                                dscbl

                                  Bep bop moxet yem etot toca toca oant yopA#N

                                  Deos

                                    Hi had game a couple of months ago vs a pudge/NP combo. Basically NP with Meteor hammer would teleport+ meteor hammer the tower and simultaneously pudge would hook him back to his original position. The whole team was just at a loss of what was happening as we would hear the MH melt our towers and cut all the trees/dust to see where the NP went, but looking back at the replay it was the pudge mechanism that did it. Pretty clever and another mechanic like these mentioned in the article. Im surprised that this hasnt been used much in pro games but im guessing coz pudge and NP arent really in the meta yet. well see. Has anyone done or seen this mechanic im decribing?

                                    Check out our newest Dotabuff App module!
                                    - game-aware build paths
                                    - real-time recommendations
                                    - build timings
                                    - and more!